Hi mama! Cetaphil Pro AD moisturizer talaga ay may subtle scent, pero yung amoy na parang baby vinegar na sinasabi mo ay weird, baka talaga old stock na yan or something went off with storage kasi October 2022 na expiration date naman, medyo matagal na talaga. A few of my mum friends use Cetaphil pero fresh ones, and wala silang nasasabing ganong amoy, so I'd honestly be cautious with that one if it doesn't smell right, lalo na kakabili mo pa lang. Pwede mo i-return o exchange kung saan mo binili, or better safe than sorry lang since it's for baby's skin!