Honestly, both have their place, the bouncer is super handy for practical moments like when you need to shower and baby needs to be somewhere safe nearby, while a rocker or swing is better for common areas where baby can chill while you do things around the house. My friend actually got both and said she ended up using the bouncer most for bathroom trips when she was home alone with her newborn, which I thought was such a smart way to think about it. Most mums I know recommend waiting until around 4 to 6 months before using a bouncer, since before that baby's neck and spine are still developing and the recline angle matters a lot, so just double-check the product specs carefully for newborn use. For bouncers specifically, 6 months is roughly when most babies start outgrowing them, so it is a fairly short window of use, which is worth keeping in mind before spending too much. Overall I would say get one that reclines flat enough for younger babies and reassess as your little one grows.