Honestly, both are decent options para sa newborn kasi vegan at rice-based talaga ang safe choices ngayon instead ng talc, a few of us have tried both and hindi kami nakakita ng malaking difference, so it really depends kung alin ang mas affordable para sa budget mo and kung paano mag-react ang skin ng baby mo. I'd say try one first, and if walang rashes or irritation after a week or two, then you're good to stick with it; every baby's skin is different din kasi, so what works for my third child didn't work sa first ko.